|
The biggest problem in health care is not cost, it is centralization of
power in the hands of insurance companies. The "managed care" (HMO) system
is designed to give insurance carriers veto power over medical treatment.
No cosmetic "patients' bill of rights" can hide the fact that managed care
is designed to ration medical treatment. That is what "managing" means,
and that is the system Tom Ridge supports.
The HMO system allows insurance companies to focus on profit, at the
expense of both medical wisdom and patient welfare. As a person who
believes all human lives must be protected, I find these arrangements
intolerable. My administration will redesign healthcare, according to
these principles:
-
Real medical choice (of doctor and treatment) must be
available to all people
-
Patients must control finance, and have a personal stake in efficiency
-
Cost, quality, access to care and patient choice are equally important
-
Public oversight is needed to protect the healthcare consumer
Our position paper
"Health Care Problems and Solutions"
explores the many ways high-deductible catastrophic insurance combined with
Medical Savings Accounts (MSAs) puts patients and doctors in the driver's
seat and cuts healthcare costs, while delivering high quality care, ensuring
patient choice and maximizing access. We must nudge the health care system
towards catastrophic insurance/MSAs.
In the meantime, here are a few of the many obstacles which must be
overcome:
-
employers must offer employees the full spectrum of health
insurance alternatives (not just identical HMOs) and full information about
costs and benefits.
-
people covered under COBRA must be offered the same group rates
they enjoyed before they lost their jobs.
-
People on welfare should be offered our MSA/Catastrophic plan. Pilot
studies by the RAND corporation show that better health care can be
delivered more cheaply to welfare clients using MSAs than traditional
welfare mechanisms.
-
College students should be eligible for coverage under their
parents policies until age 23.
-
The insurance commissioner must establish a minimum proportion of
health insurance income (say 80%) to be devoted to actual patient care,
exclusive of marketing and administrative overhead. There should be an
oversight board, controlled by physicians and patients, to fine-tune needed
regulations.
-
All insurance policies, public or private, should cover
catastrophic illness, so no one can be bankrupted by medical expenses.
It took us the better part of this century to create the mess our medical
system has become. It will take time, good will and public spirit to clean
up the mess, but together we can have a cost-efficient system which ensures
patient choice, and universal access to high quality care. Health reform
will have high priority in the Luksik administration.
|